Assessment, Grading, and Differentiation
Assessment, Grading, and Differentiation
Most kids never talk about it, but a lot of the time, bad grades make them feel dumb, and almost all the time it's not true. And good grades can make other kids think that they're better, and that's not true either. And then all the kids start competing and comparing. And the people who are supposed to help kids, they don't. They just add more pressure and keep making up more and more tests. Andrew Clements, The Report Card
At the beginning of my (Carol's) third year of teaching, a very quiet, shy, courageous, small boy whispered something to me in the hall during the change on the sixth day of school. His barely articulated words were lost in the chatter and energy of several hundred students moving from second period to third. After several failed attempts to have him speak louder and for me to listen "harder," I heard what he was saying. I thought he was asking me to help him open his locker, a predictable request for 7th graders who were new to lockers and middle school. What he was saying to me, however, reflected a need far more profound and challenging for both of us. What he whispered to the very tall lady he had never seen before was this: "I can't read." He was 15 and, as I learned from his crumpled class schedule, he was about to join my 7th grade language arts class composed of thirty-five 12-year-olds. He had missed the first week of school. He could not yet write the entire alphabet.
A herd of questions trampled through my brain. How did he get this far if he can't read? (Irrelevant question. He's mine.) How do you teach reading? (Also irrelevant. No time for a course right now. Figure it out.) Do I let the other kids know he has special need or do I try to disguise it? (How do I help a 15-year-old nonreader feel a sense of belonging and dignity in a 7th grade class that's based on reading?) How do I find time to teach him? (What happens if I quit paying attention to the other 34 kids in order to work with him?) Where do I seat him in the room? (Next to a good reader who can help him? Near my desk across the world.
I had to figure out what my any mandate that all starting points, Golden would have been failure—and so they would. I spring, but no matter still believe that my grandest accomplishment as a teacher was working with Golden in a coherent and sustained way so that together, we moved him forward as a reader more than three grade levels in one school year.
One question Golden's presence evoked in me was harder to answer than the rest. That question was "How do I grade him?"
school. Understanding that clearly, I felt that to be honest with him I needed to say the truth. I [unintelligible] because [unintelligible]. Still, I hope you'll come to school every day really excited to learn." I didn't say that to him explicitly, of course, but the idea reflected in the “statement of truth” that ripped through my head in the hallway stayed with me.
What would happen if Golden stayed struggling for two or five years? What about those two or five years above grade level? Are there redemptive measures for them in our system of grades and report cards?
The purpose of this chapter is not to provide a digest of general grading theory and practice, but rather understanding how we can investigate (and how we shouldn't) best grading practices about grades and reporting so that students like Golden, students who are advanced, and students in between are well served by our grading practices.
ABitof Background
ABitof Background
Paul Dressel of Michigan State University defined grading in a way that likely represents the musings of many teachers at all levels around report card time at some point in their careers.A grade is six"an inadequate report of fan imprecise judgment of a biased and variable judge of the extent to which a student has attained an undefined level ofmastery on an unknown proportion of an indefinite 司amount a of material.(ppoint one two).
Grades have massive power in our schools andin the lives ofthe pople whomwe grade.We often speak of grading as though it were somehow sanctified —a thing that has to be as it has always been because to change the system would someho disruption too great to bear.In truth,grades run through human filters.They are subjective.They are messy.It's probably healthier to give credence to Dressel's view than to the reverence that often prevails in conversations about E grading.E
Tonya is fond of saying that he no real problem with grades and diff erentiation.The problem is that grading practices in general aresuch a mess that grades plus anything creates an issue.And yet,there is a literature on best practices in grading,developed by experts who study and research the topic carefully.Any consideration of grading and diff erentiation needs to begin with at least brief explanation ofthe purposes of fgrading as defined by those with expertise in this area.The longer discussion that then follows on grading and differentiation ought also to refl ect our best knowledge of sound grading practices that stem from the field ofmeasurement as opposed to emanating from "how e'e always done things here.In regard to that last point,Ken O'Connor off ers relevant observation when he notes that although "we know more than we ever knew about how people learn,traditional grading practices persist.These practices often not only result in ineff ective communication,but may also may actually harm students and misrepresent their learning (pp xi-xii).
E The purpose of grades,strictly speaking,is c to communicate information about a pupil's academic achievement Grading is a process in which teacher transforms assessment data into meaningful information about pupil p performe is conveyed to pupils, parents,and others (Airasian,nineteen ninety-seven,?two hundred sixty-one).This brief explanation highlights three elements worth remembering.First,the primary goal of grading should be to help parents and students (as well as other stakeholders)know where a student currently stands in terms of academic achievement,with achievement defined as "performance suggests,are numbers of a student's performance.
to students,their parents,Thesea students student (for example,academicperformance.rka motivating students tolearn,computing class or punishwith;aduge.sto the.These grading students and uses process.(four)of grades in teacher classes;Using have and (four)grades conflicting purposes program providing for all evaluation teachers ofthese purposescallsiestine validity ofthe grades for any of the purposes.More oe grading makes it almost impossible understand,and can doata to support student learping element in the teaching-Secacitlcarnig learning-asssmtcle,tattacsand ther educators understandfundamental i to ensure that the principles are reflected in thegrading and reporting process.The following section describes four imoreoolit validity, and teacher bias.

