Note on the Relationship Between Artificial Intelligence and Human Intelligence

DICASTERY FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH DICASTERY FOR CULTURE AND EDUCATION

ANTIQUA ET NOVA

Note on the Relationship Between Artificial Intelligence and Human Intelligence

Section One. Introduction

One. With wisdom both ancient and new, we are called to reflect on the current challenges and opportunities posed by scientific and technological advancements, particularly by the recent development of Artificial Intelligence. The Christian tradition regards the gift of intelligence as an essential aspect of how humans are created "in the image of God." Starting from an integral vision of the human person and the biblical calling to "till" and "keep" the earth, the Church emphasizes that this gift of intelligence should be expressed through the responsible use of reason and technical abilities in the stewardship of the created world.

Two. The Church encourages the advancement of science, technology, the arts, and other forms of human endeavor, viewing them as part of the "collaboration of man and woman with God in perfecting the visible creation." As Sirach affirms, God "gave skill to human beings, that he might be glorified in his marvelous works." Human abilities and creativity come from God and, when used rightly, glorify God by reflecting his wisdom and goodness. In light of this, when we ask ourselves what it means to "be human," we cannot exclude a consideration of our scientific and technological abilities.

Three. It is within this perspective that the present Note addresses the anthropological and ethical challenges raised by Al-issues that are particularly significant, as one of the goals of this technology is to imitate the human intelligence that designed it. For instance, unlike many other human creations, Al can be trained on the results of human creativity and then generate new "artifacts" with a level of speed and skill that often rivals or surpasses what humans can do, such as producing text or images indistinguishable from human compositions. This raises critical concerns about Al's potential role in the growing crisis of truth in the public forum. Moreover, this technology is designed to learn and make certain choices autonomously, adapting to new situations and providing solutions not foreseen by its programmers, and thus, it raises fundamental questions about ethical responsibility and human safety, with broader implications for society as a whole. This new situation has prompted many people to reflect on what it means to be human and the role of humanity in the world.

Four. Taking all this into account, there is broad consensus that Al marks a new and significant phase in humanity's engagement with technology, placing it at the heart of what Pope Francis has described as an "epochal change." Its impact is felt globally and in a wide range of areas, including interpersonal relationships, education, work, art, healthcare, law, warfare, and international relations. As Al advances rapidly toward even greater achievements, it is critically important to consider its anthropological and ethical implications. This involves not only mitigating risks and preventing harm but also ensuring that its applications are used to promote human progress and the common good.

Five. To contribute positively to the discernment regarding Al, and in response to Pope Francis' call for a renewed "wisdom of heart," the Church offers its experience through the anthropological and ethical reflections contained in this Note. Committed to its active role in the global dialogue on these issues, the Church invites those entrusted with transmitting the faith-including parents, teachers, pastors, and bishops-to dedicate themselves to this critical subject with care and attention. While this document is intended especially for them, it is also meant to be accessible to a broader audience, particularly those who share the conviction that scientific and technological advances should be directed toward serving the human person and the common good.

Six. To this end, the document begins by distinguishing between concepts of intelligence in Al and in human intelligence. It then explores the Christian understanding of human intelligence, providing a framework rooted in the Church's philosophical and theological tradition. Finally, the document offers guidelines to ensure that the development and use of Al uphold human dignity and promote the integral development of the human person and society.