Chapter 1
Chapter 1
Use of the REVERT total protein stain as a loading control demonstrates significant benefits over the use of housekeeping proteins when analyzing brain homogenates by Western blot: An analysis of samples representing different gonadal hormone states
Abstract
Western blot is routinely used to quantify differences in the levels of target proteins in tissues. Standard methods typically use measurements of housekeeping proteins to control for variations in loading and protein transfer. This is problematic, however, when housekeeping proteins also are affected by experimental conditions such as injury, disease, and/or gonadal hormone manipulations. Our goal was to evaluate an alternative and perhaps superior method for conducting Western blot analysis of brain tissue homogenates from rats with distinct physiologically relevant gonadal hormone states. Tissues were collected from the hippocampus, frontal cortex, and striatum of young adult female rats that either were ovariectomized to model surgical menopause, or were treated with the ovatotoxin 4-vinylcyclohexene diepoxide (VCD) to model transitional menopause. Tissues also were collected from rats with a normal estrous cycle killed at proestrus when estradiol levels are high, and at diestrus when estradiol levels are low. Western blot detection of alpha-tubulin, beta-actin, and GAPDH was performed and were compared for sensitivity and reliability with a fluorescent total protein stain (REVERT). Results show that the total protein stain was much less variable across samples and had a greater linear range than alpha-tubulin, beta-actin, or GAPDH. The stain was stable and easy to use, and did not interfere with the immunodetection or multiplexed detection of the housekeeping proteins. In addition, we show that normalization of our data to total protein, but not to GAPDH, revealed significant differences in alpha-tubulin expression in the hippocampus as a function of treatment, and that gel-to-gel consistency in measuring differences between paired samples run on multiple gels was significantly better when data were normalized to total protein than when normalized to GAPDH. These results demonstrate that the REVERT total protein stain can be used in Western blot analysis of brain tissue homogenates to control for variations in loading and protein transfer, and provides significant advantages over the use of housekeeping proteins for quantifying changes in the levels of multiple target proteins.
Keywords
Keywords
1. Introduction
Gonadal hormones affect the brain through a multitude of mechanisms involving all regions of the cell. Estradiol in particular has been shown to produce well-documented effects on cellular metabolism, synaptic plasticity, brain growth and development, neuronal maintenance and repair, sex and social behaviors, and learning and memory . These effects are mediated by estrogen receptors (E Rs) and correspond with changes in both gene and protein expression in specific regions of the brain.
Several methods are available to study changes in protein expression in brain. These include spectrometry methods such as H P L C and L C slash M S; and also antibody-dependent methods such as enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (E L I S A), radioimmunoassay (R I A) and Western blot. Western blot evolved from northern blotting with the addition of electrophoretic transfer and the use of secondary antibodies to allow protein quantification by optical densitometry . Further advances such as the acquisition of images using high dynamic range detectors (such as C C Ds) and the use of fluorescently-labeled secondary antibodies have led to increased detection sensitivity, a broader linear range of signal quantification, and have enabled multiplex detection of multiple proteins simultaneously . Quantitative Western blot became a common and well-established methodology as a result of being easy to perform, cost-efficient, and its ability to be used with a variety of visualization methods for quantifying relative amounts of protein.
A common practice in quantitative Western blot analysis is to normalize the intensity of bands representing target proteins to a housekeeping protein, H K P, that is present in high abundance and assumed to be unaffected by treatment. This controls for variations in loading and transfer that can affect band intensity and quantification. In studies involving estrogen regulation of proteins in the central nervous system, it is common practice to normalize target proteins to one of three H K Ps, beta-actin, G A P D H, or alpha-tubulin.
To verify how common this is, we conducted a search of publications using the PubMed advanced search engine to identify publications in which (a) circulating estrogens were manipulated in rats or mice by either ovariectomy and/or estradiol treatment, and (b) Western blot methods were used to quantify changes in one or more target proteins in the brain. Our analysis was limited to 50 papers published in the last 4 years (2013 to 2017). The specific H K Ps that were used to normalize Western blot data were noted and frequency of use was quantified. The results of this survey are summarized in supplementary table 1. Of the 50 publications surveyed, 32 (64%) normalized target proteins to actin, 9 (18%) normalized to G A P D H, and 9 (18%) normalized to tubulin.
Studies have reported, however, that, in many tissues, these same H K Ps are themselves targets of estrogen regulation . This raises concerns about the use of H K Ps in the estrogen field as normalization controls for Western blot analyses, and about the interpretation of data based on these methods.
An alternative approach is to use total protein, T P, staining in place of H K Ps as an internal control. T P stain enables one to combine signal densitometry from all proteins in a defined molecular weight range in order to represent the T P content. Some T P stains can be applied on a gel to represent amount of loaded protein; while some can be applied directly on polyvinylidene difluoride, P V D F, or nitrocellulose membrane. In each case, signal generated by the T P stain represents the whole-sample proteome. Therefore, any set of changes caused by hormonal manipulations will be proportional to the T P content and less variable between samples. Indeed, a number of studies have reported on the use of T P as a reliable loading control for Western blot quantification . Despite these advantages and the lack of a reliable H K P, normalization by T P stain has not yet been evaluated as a suitable loading control for protein quantification in brain samples obtained at different stages of the estrus cycle or following other gonadal or hormonal manipulations.
Here we evaluated the REVERT (L I-C O R, Incorporated) T P stain as an internal control in Western blot analyses. This was compared with commonly used H K Ps to quantify changes in the levels of target proteins in the brains of rats being used to model surgical versus transitional menopause, as well as in tissues collected at proestrus and diestrus.
Our results demonstrate significant benefits of using T P to normalize loading when quantifying protein levels by Western blot. In addition, we detected significant effects of menopausal model on H K Ps, but not T P, and show that these differences are of sufficient magnitude to alter conclusions about effects of ovarian manipulations on protein expression. We conclude that the described T P stain is a more reliable and precise method than the alternative of using a single common H K P as an internal control when evaluating effects of hormone manipulations on target proteins in the central nervous system.

