Chapter 1
Chapter 1
Cross Platform Narrative Infrastructures: Towards an Understanding of the Narrative Mechanics of Right Wing Populist emergence (and what to do about it)
Abstract
This paper elaborates on a theory of cross platform narrative infrastructures to help explain how right wing populist movements emerge on national political stages worldwide. Narrative infrastructures involve a mix of technologies, institutions, and cultural habits that make some stories easier to tell than others. This paper looks at three cases: the rise of the Tea Party in the U.S. in 2010 (which helped set the stage for the MAGA movement), the 2013 Jornadas de Junho (June Days) in Brazil (which helped create the platform for Jair Bolsonaro's election in 2018), and the Canadian Trucker Convoy of 2022 (which nearly propelled a right wing populist into the Prime Minister's office). All of these cases share certain patterns: an outbreak of protests that rely on internet platforms for coordination and solidarity while exploiting a mainstream press that is both attracted to and bewildered by the protests, politicians that turn the protests into a springboard towards power, and a resulting rupture in the norms and boundaries of political behavior and discourse. The emergence of social media, the related decline of traditional journalism's agenda-setting power, and the persistence of conventional journalistic routines such as balancing and vox pop coverage that are vulnerable to trolling, together create a storytelling environment that enables narratives that support grievance for its own sake and undermine shared truths. Better awareness of these dynamics on the part of journalists, activists, and politicians could help render political narrative environments that are more conducive to democracy.
Introduction
Introduction
It's by now disturbingly familiar: another established electoral democracy thought to be immune to authoritarianism suddenly faces, as if from nowhere, a wave of protests or disturbances whose political demands seem confused but nonetheless garner widespread attention from both the press and politicians. The movements, armed more with slogans, attitude, and fanciful accusations cultivated in online enclaves than with clear policy proposals, go on to break unwritten rules, prompt friendly politicians to say and do things that would have ended the careers of politicians prior, and upend the political dynamics of their country. Journalists print corrective interviews with experts, politicians alternately try to ignore, mimic, or disparage the new entrants, intellectuals grope for underlying causes such as the collapse of the "center," or reactions to income inequality. None of this seems to have an effect, and the movements gain political power while forms of ethnocentrism, racism, misogyny, and queerphobia once thought behind us are revived with new virulence. Electorally, the movements sometimes win and sometimes lose, but they show no signs of disappearing. The story, with variations, has repeated itself in the U.S., India, Brazil, Sweden, Argentina, Holland, Germany, and Canada, among others.
A national conversation is built out of multiple ongoing narratives, and in ordinary times those narratives tend to flow in well-worn channels made of media systems, institutional structures and habits, and popular memories. Sometimes, however, something happens that causes the conversation to jump its banks and start to flow in new paths, rearranging the political landscape. In the 19th century, the steam-powered penny press and expansion of suffrage arguably had that effect. In the 20th, mass advertising techniques and broadcasting similarly changed the contours of the conversation. In both centuries, major wars also had discourse-altering impact. As Raymond Williams said to a pre-war friend about the feeling of returning to Cambridge after World War Two, "the fact is, they just don't speak the same language" .
This paper proposes an approach to understanding the rise of right wing populism over the last two decades as a kind of linguistic, and more specifically, narrative transformation. Building on work by Papacharissi , it offers the concept of "cross platform narrative infrastructures," environments built of multiple institutions, socio-technical arrangements, and cultural habits which taken together make some stories easier to tell than others. Right wing populism, this analysis suggests, still relies on mainstream news coverage for visibility and a kind of legitimacy centered on perceived impact – where negative coverage can be seen as success – while using social media to cultivate oppositional interpretations and a sense of community. It emerges not by simply creating alternative meanings in online enclaves, but in an interactive relationship with both friendly and hostile political officials while exploiting traditional journalistic routines to "troll" the dominant narratives from within alternate interpretive frames. This is particularly effective when established communicators operate according to traditional rules and expectations in a context where right wing populists are operating by very different rules.
Narrative infrastructures are most visible in a moment of change, when new structures emerge; once they are established; once they become habitual the channels get dug in, they become both less visible and more robust, developing some capacity to self-sustain over time. This is why I focus on three case studies of emergence: 1) the rise of the Tea Party in the U.S. in 2009 (which set the stage for the MAGA movement), 2) the 2013 Jornadas de Junho (June Days) in Brazil (which helped create the context for Jair Bolsonaro's election in 2018), and 3) the Canadian Trucker Convoy of 2022 (which nearly propelled a right wing populist into the Prime Minister's office). While distinct, all of these cases share certain patterns: an outbreak of protests that rely on internet platforms for coordination and solidarity, a mainstream press that is both attracted to and bewildered by the protests, politicians that use the protests as a springboard towards power, and a resulting rupture in the norms and boundaries of political behavior and discourse.

