Social Media and its Negative Impacts on Autonomy
Social Media and its Negative Impacts on Autonomy
Abstract
How social media impacts the autonomy of its users is a topic of increasing focus. However, much of the literature that explores these impacts fails to engage in depth with the philosophical literature on autonomy. This has resulted in a failure to consider the full range of impacts that social media might have on autonomy. A deeper consideration of these impacts is thus needed, given the importance of both autonomy as a moral concept and social media as a feature of contemporary life. By drawing on this philosophical literature, we argue that autonomy is broadly a matter of developing autonomy competencies, having authentic ends and control over key aspects of your own life, and not being manipulated, coerced, and controlled by others. We show how the autonomy of users of social media can be disrespected and harmed through the control that social media can have over its users' data, attention, and behaviour. We conclude by discussing various recommendations to better regulate social media.
1 Introduction
1 Introduction
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in the literature into the ways in which digital technologies, and specifically social media, impact on the autonomy of its users (e.g. ; ). While the impacts of new technology on autonomy have been explored in areas such as Artificial Intelligence ( ) and social robotics ( ), much of the literature that explores the impacts of social media on autonomy fails to engage in depth with the philosophical literature on autonomy. This has resulted in a failure to consider the full range of impacts that social media might have on the various aspects of autonomy.
A deeper consideration of these impacts is therefore needed, given the importance of both autonomy as a moral concept and social media as a feature of contemporary life. This paper will explore these issues as follows. First, we survey different conceptions of autonomy found in the philosophical literature and argue that autonomy is broadly a matter of developing autonomy competencies, having authentic ends and control over key aspects of your own life, and not being manipulated, coerced, and controlled by others. We then detail what we mean by social media and focus on the control that it can have over users' data, attention, and behaviour. We outline three related but distinct autonomy harms this control can inflict on the users of social media: (1) disrespecting their autonomy; (2) interfering with the exercise of their autonomy; and (3) impairing the maintenance or development of their autonomy competencies. Finally, we end with recommendations for better regulating social media to limit the harm it can have on the autonomy of its users.

