Relational values resonate broadly and differently than intrinsic or instrumental values, or the New Ecological Paradigm

Summary

Value orientations used to explain or justify conservation have been rooted in arguments about how much and in what context to emphasize the intrinsic versus instrumental value of nature. Equally prominent are characterizations of beliefs known as the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP), often used to help explain pro-environmental behaviour. A recent alternative to these positions has been identified as ‘relational value’—broadly, values linking people and ecosystems via tangible and intangible relationships to nature as well as the principles, virtues and notions of a good life that may accompany these. This paper examines whether relational values are distinct from other value orientation and have potential to alleviate the intrinsic-instrumental debate. To test this possibility, we sought to operationalize the construct—relational values—by developing six relational statements. We ask: 1) Do the individual statements used to characterize relational values demonstrate internal coherence as either a single or multi-dimensional construct? 2) Do relational value statements (including those strongly stated) resonate with diverse populations? 3) Do people respond to relational value statements in a consistently different way than NEP scale statements? Data for this work is drawn from an online panel of residents of northeastern US (n = 400), as well as a sample of Costa Rican farmers (n = 253) and tourists in Costa Rica (n = 260). Results indicate relational values are distinct as a construct when compared to the NEP.

Related articles

• Introduction to Applied Social Sciences

  This document provides an overview of applied social sciences, covering its interdisciplinary nature and various related disciplines such as counseling, social work, and communication. It discusses the relevance of theoretical frameworks in addressing societal issues and enhancing human well-being.

• Impact Evaluation in Practice SECOND EDITION

  This document is the second edition of "Impact Evaluation in Practice," which provides comprehensive guidance on conducting impact evaluations to inform policy-making in various sectors such as education, health, and social services. It focuses on methodologies for assessing the effectiveness of development programs, offering practical advice on planning, executing, and interpreting evaluations.

• RELIGIOUS COMMUNITY AND PRACTICES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF FUNERAL CEREMONIES AT THE KOCATEPE MOSQUE AND THE HACIBAYRAM MOSQUE

  This thesis examines the differences between religious communities and practices through a comparative study of funeral ceremonies at Kocatepe Mosque and Hacibayram Mosque in Ankara. Utilizing ethnographic data collected from eighty-seven ceremonies, it investigates ceremonial patterns and the factors influencing ritual differentiation.

• The Kula: An Economic Phenomenon in the South Sea Islands

  This document explores the navigational and trading practices of coastal populations in the South Sea Islands, particularly focusing on the Kula trading system among the Papuo-Melanesians and surrounding tribes of New Guinea. It discusses the cultural significance and economic implications of these trade routes.

• The Kula: An Ethnographic Study of the Trading System in the South Sea Islands

  This document explores the Kula, a complex trading system among coastal populations of the South Sea Islands, particularly focusing on the transformative impact it has on tribal life and social relations. It discusses the methods of ethnographic data collection in this context.