Relational values resonate broadly and differently than intrinsic or instrumental values, or the New Ecological Paradigm

Summary

Value orientations used to explain or justify conservation have been rooted in arguments about how much and in what context to emphasize the intrinsic versus instrumental value of nature. Equally prominent are characterizations of beliefs known as the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP), often used to help explain pro-environmental behaviour. A recent alternative to these positions has been identified as ‘relational value’—broadly, values linking people and ecosystems via tangible and intangible relationships to nature as well as the principles, virtues and notions of a good life that may accompany these. This paper examines whether relational values are distinct from other value orientation and have potential to alleviate the intrinsic-instrumental debate. To test this possibility, we sought to operationalize the construct—relational values—by developing six relational statements. We ask: 1) Do the individual statements used to characterize relational values demonstrate internal coherence as either a single or multi-dimensional construct? 2) Do relational value statements (including those strongly stated) resonate with diverse populations? 3) Do people respond to relational value statements in a consistently different way than NEP scale statements? Data for this work is drawn from an online panel of residents of northeastern US (n = 400), as well as a sample of Costa Rican farmers (n = 253) and tourists in Costa Rica (n = 260). Results indicate relational values are distinct as a construct when compared to the NEP.

Key Points

• 1Relational values link people to ecosystems via diverse relationships
• 2The study tests relational values against the New Ecological Paradigm
• 3Results indicate relational values are distinct and promote understanding of pro-environmental behavior
• 4The research draws on diverse populations, including residents from the U.S. and farmers in Costa Rica
• 5Internal coherence of relational value statements is investigated through surveys.

Related articles

• Towards a continental-scale biodiversity monitoring network to assess climate-driven change in bat communities and inform European Union conservation policy

  This article discusses the creation of a European-scale monitoring network designed to assess the impact of climate change on bat communities. It aims to provide decision-makers with robust data to inform conservation strategies across the continent.

• New Leasing Languages - How Green Leasing Programs Can Help Overcome the Split Incentive

  This document discusses the challenges posed by the split incentive in commercial leasing and presents green leasing as a viable solution to enhance energy efficiency in leased spaces. It highlights the significance of the Green Lease Leaders program in promoting sustainable leasing practices.

• Green Leasing Program Design for PSU

  This report outlines the design of a Green Leasing Program implemented by Portland State University to promote sustainability practices among its third-party tenants. It includes research on best practices for green leasing and recommendations for tenant engagement and incentive-based approaches.

• Introduction to Environmental Management

  This document provides an overview of environmental management, discussing key concepts, resources, management strategies, and the significance of various government initiatives in preserving the natural environment.

• Handout 4

  This document explores the dynamic relationship between tourism and the environment, assessing both the positive and negative impacts of tourism activities on ecological health and sustainability. It provides insights into how sustainable tourism practices can enhance environmental preservation while also highlighting the adverse effects associated with unsustainable tourism development.