Relationship between Funding Source and Conclusion among Nutrition-Related Scientific Articles

Summary

Background Industrial support of biomedical research may bias scientific conclusions, as demonstrated by recent analyses of pharmaceutical studies. However, this issue has not been systematically examined in the area of nutrition research. The purpose of this study is to characterize financial sponsorship of scientific articles addressing the health effects of three commonly consumed beverages, and to determine how sponsorship affects published conclusions. Methods and Findings Medline searches of worldwide literature were used to identify three article types (interventional studies, observational studies, and scientific reviews) about soft drinks, juice, and milk published between 1 January, 1999 and 31 December, 2003. Financial sponsorship and article conclusions were classified by independent groups of coinvestigators. The relationship between sponsorship and conclusions was explored by exact tests and regression analyses, controlling for covariates. 206 articles were included in the study, of which 111 declared financial sponsorship. Of these, 22% had all industry funding, 47% had no industry funding, and 32% had mixed funding. Funding source was significantly related to conclusions when considering all article types (p = 0.037). For interventional studies, the proportion with unfavorable conclusions was 0% for all industry funding versus 37% for no industry funding (p = 0.009). The odds ratio of a favorable versus unfavorable conclusion was 7.61 (95% confidence interval 1.27 to 45.73), comparing articles with all industry funding to no industry funding. Conclusions Industry funding of nutrition-related scientific articles may bias conclusions in favor of sponsors' products, with potentially significant implications for public health.

Related articles

• Shoulder Trauma and Hypomobility

  This chapter focuses on the optimal functioning of the shoulder and arm, discussing the anatomy, biomechanics, and rehabilitation principles for managing shoulder injuries. It emphasizes the importance of understanding both normal and abnormal shoulder function to enhance recovery and rehabilitation outcomes.

• Small Bowel Post Endoscopy Approach

  This document discusses the approach to diagnosing and treating patients with small bowel disorders, particularly following endoscopic procedures. It explores the physiology, common causes of symptoms, and diagnostic methods for conditions affecting the small intestine.

• COMMUNITY HEALTH NURSING

  This document discusses various aspects of community health nursing, covering topics such as health promotion, maternal and child health, mental health, and public health nursing principles. It emphasizes the importance of nursing practice in community settings and provides insight into relevant legislation and health care delivery systems.

• The Personal Health Inventory

  This document provides a comprehensive overview of the Personal Health Inventory, emphasizing health-related fitness, barriers to physical activity participation, and actionable strategies for goal-setting and overcoming obstacles to exercise.

• Anatomy of an Illness: As Perceived by the Patient - Reflections on Healing and Regeneration

  This book narrates Norman Cousins' personal fight against a crippling disease and illustrates the collaboration between a patient and his physician in overcoming illness through the power of laughter, courage, and tenacity, emphasizing the patient's role in their own recovery.